Friday, August 12, 2011

Formspring Question #220--Evaluating the Gun Culture Edition

What did you mean when you said you did not like the gun culture? What do rednecks have to do with it?
I knew time I wrote that answer someone was going to ask more about it. This should make me really popular in certain conservative circles. Here goes…



There are three reasons to own a gun as far as I can tell; protection, sport, and as a theoretical shield against government tyranny. I think the first reason is the strongest personally. If some guy comes crawling in through your window in the middle of the night, put a bullet in his butt. He is up to no good. There, he deserves it.



I am fine with owning a gun for sport, but I do not care it myself. I have never been hunting. I fished frequently up until recent years, including deep sea fishing, but I do not hunt. It is not that I am an animal rights activist, I just do not see the fun in it. The argument you have to kill deer to keep them from starving to death echoes the ridiculous we had to destroy the village in order to save it logic that I have never bought into. I have been to and participated in shooting ranges before. The appeal is lost on me. I grew up in an area where seven year old kids care about nothing but gun shooting, deer hunting, NASCAR, and riding 4-wheelers. This is the culture I say I do not like. The inherently shallow, redneck way makes my teeth hurt.



The final point with guns as a barrier against government tyranny is tricky. I believe that is a valid reason to own a gun. As an individualist, I wholeheartedly believe a government should fear its citizens, not the other way around. But here is the imperative question to answer--what does the government have to do to merit its overthrow? Have you ever really thought about it?



Look at it from a conservative perspective. The government has done everything from enact unpopular legislation against the will of the electorate on the relatively innocent side to murdering citizens at Ruby Ridge and Waco while engaging in misinformation and likely covering up its wrongdoing. If you are a progressive, you may genuinely believe the unelected supreme Court enacted an undemocratic coup by appointing Bush 43 president against the will of the majority of voters. If you are a conspiracy theorist, you may think the government orchestrated 9/11, murdered JFK, or knew of the Japanese plan to attack Pearl Harbor and let it happen as a casus belli to enter World War II.



Throw in your favorite scandals while you are it. Fact is, the government has given gun owners to overthrow it depending on your persuasions, but it has not even come close to happening. Nor will it, I think. I would like to be optimistic and say it is because we still have faith in the mechanics of democracy. If we have a bad government, we can voyte it out of office without violence. But I am not much of an optimist. I am more inclined to think we are fat, dumb, and happy, and therefore really do not care about government overstepping its bounds, even when it means people will lose their lives. Heck, especially when people lose their lives. It seems like anytime the government kills someone, there is an assumption the person got what he deserved.



I cannot answer the question of what line the government has to cross to merit its destruction, either. Contemplating the issue itself makes one wonder about the line between patriot and traitor. It is not as clear a line as you might like to think. Whoever believes they can draw that line in the sand, in consideration of the government acts I mentioned above, must have reached his conclusion as a flight of fancy. Or maybe he just wants to justify playing with his guns when he has no nerve whatsoever to turn them on a tyrannical government. Whichever the case, I am not eager to draw a line myself. I do not like the culture that says I need to do so.

No comments:

Post a Comment