Why did you dog David Duchovny so badly for grumbling publicly about X-Files, but give Robert Beltran a free pass for criticizing Voyager?Four reasons:
One, these are opinionated reviews. Everything said about thse shows is how I personally feel. I like The X-Files, but I do not like VOY. When david Duchovny criticizes The X-Files or its fans, he is attacking something for which I have a postive emotional attachment. When Robert Beltran attacked VOY or weirdo Trekkies, I could see he had a point.
Two, Mulder is a much better character than Chakotay. Iconic, even. The name mulder is so much in the public conscious that just hearing it makes even non-X-Philes think of conspiracy theories. It is just my opinion as I said above, because I do not what kind of career opportunities float any particular actor’s boat, but I would think being associated with such a role would be cause for more gratitude. Chakotay is different. I do not think the character was as well developed as it could have been. If Beltran was irritated to spend seven years playing a character he did not like, I am sympathetic.
Three, money. Duchovny got rich of playing Mulder. As one who bought a ticket to see Fight the Future and bought the DVD sets, I helped him get rich. Duchovny made so much money, he sued 20th Century Fox for $25 million in lost earning, so you know he must have made a ton more. Beltran was not so financially blessed for his work.
Finally, Duchovny comes off like jerk. He criticized fans. He sued his employer. He basically said his costar Gillian Anderson was a sucker for not suing for a greater piece of the pie herself. In contrast, beltran seems like a good guy. He hung in with VOY even when he did not want to do so. He makes convention appearances these days because fans have not forgotten him. He does a lot of charity work for Downs Syndrome research on behalf og his younger sister who suffers from the disease. It is hard to hold a grudge against the guy.
All four of these reasons are subjective. You can accuse them of being weak and/or hypocritical if you so desire. But this is how I feel about the issue.
No comments:
Post a Comment